Jump to Navigation

Custody evaluators can be biased towards battered moms

Domestic violence is not a new issue that women and children in Michigan deal with. However, despite the public attention it has received, a report shows that a large number of court officials have beliefs about battered mothers that can influence their decisions over custody. The report, which was submitted to the National Institute of Justice, was based on a survey conducted on more than 1100 people connected to the topic, including some survivors of abuse, attorneys, judges, workers in domestic violence programs and custody evaluators.

When researchers went through all of the responses from those surveyed, they discovered that experiences with domestic violence itself greatly influenced their beliefs about the issue and their decisions concerning custody recommendations. Not surprisingly, those who worked directly with victims, had seen domestic violence firsthand or knew someone were more likely to believe a mother’s claim of violence and abuse than those who did not. Additionally, officials who had undergone training on the matter were also more prone to believe.

The officials who were most likely to dismiss a mother’s claim were the evaluators, judges and attorneys. The revelation showed that there was still much education that was needed for court officials. The report also revealed that women in these positions would believe victims more than their male counterparts. As a result, battered mothers who were interviewed related stories of how the judge or evaluator forced them to share custody with their abuser and were not sympathetic to their situation.

Part of the reason for this belief may be the fact that research has shown abusers push for custody more than non-abusive fathers. The Advocates for Human Rights states that abusers see the court system as a way to further victimize the mother. However, as courts are embracing the idea that custody should be shared equally, battered mothers who object to the idea are seen as uncooperative and can find themselves at a distinct disadvantage.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Lorrie J. Zahodnic

"I will hold you up until you can stand on your own two feet."

Lorrie J. Zahodnic, P.C. has provided skilled and compassionate legal guidance to Michiganders in family law matters for over 20 years.

Learn More About Lorrie
Have A Question? Ask Lorrie

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

Subscribe To This Blog’s Feed
Review Us
FindLaw Network